Monthly Archives: December 2007

“Before I Die” by Jenny Downham


I recently read Chris Crutcher's "Deadline" (reviewed below), which tells the alternately funny and touching story of a dying teen's last year on Earth, during which he triumphs, finds love, and struggles to accept his fate. How strange, then, to find another "teen dies of fatal illness" novel published mere months after "Deadline," one which also follows the same general plot line. Is this the new wave in teen fiction?

It's unfortunate to have to compare the two books, but it's natural — isn't it? — to measure one slowly fading teen's story against another. Essentially, "Before I Die" is "Deadline" set in England with a female lead character and an overall harder, more abrasive edge. Tessa is dying of leukemia, and when this fact becomes clear, she embarks on a somewhat misguided effort to fulfill a list of things to do before she dies. Tessa has a very authentic voice, and she acts, sounds, and talks like a real teenager. This means that Tessa can be petty, spoiled, petulant, and selfish. As such, this also means that Tessa can be a tough character to like and support at times. Her behavior is often so self-destructive (sex with a stranger, diving into a filthy river on a whim, shoplifting, fleeing a hospital stay, etc.), that, while you may in theory want to support a character who is trying to squeeze all life's experiences into a short window of time, you can't help but be annoyed at her antics. Even worse, Tessa's dad is portrayed as so steady, caring, and long suffering that it's difficult to separate Tessa's desire to live and create memories from the awful effects of her behavior on poor dad.

Publishers Weekly and Kirkus Reviews recently named "Before I Die" one of the best teen books of 2007, and it's easy to see why. Author Jenny Downham has a lovely writing style, and she's able to nicely intersperse descriptions and observations that feel like bits of poetry into Tessa's account of her final year. I thought the second half of the novel, after Tessa opens herself up to her neighbor Adam, loses and regains love, and watches angrily as her health rapidly declines, was quite beautiful to read. Downham is able to create real emotion at Tessa's end, but not in a saccharine or falsely sympathetic way.

Most likely, girls will be drawn to Tessa's story, and I have no problem recommending it to high school readers. There is an abundance of serious subject matter here — death, sex, drugs, crime, teen pregnancy — so it's definitely a story for older teens. If you give it a try, let us know what you think.


Posted by on December 20, 2007 in Uncategorized


Tags: , , , , , , , ,

“Freak” by Marcella Pixley


Seventh grader Miriam Fisher is the "freak" of the book's title. She's a poetry-writing, flat-chested, mostly friendless middle school girl who is routinely mocked, teased, and tormented by her classmates. Miriam thinks her life is about to change for the better when family friend Artie Rosenberg moves in during his senior year of high school. Artie is a handsome, smart, popular boy who acts in plays and reads poetry. In the past, he has seemed to genuinely like Miriam, treating her kindly and sharing poems and stories with her. But Miriam quickly realizes that times have changed. Artie now sees her as only a smart, ugly little kid. It's Miriam's sister, popular, pretty freshman Deborah, who truly catches Artie's eye. After "losing" Artie, Miriam's whole life seems to spiral downward, as the bullying at school, particularly by ultimate "watermelon girl" Jenny Clarke, intensifies to an unbearable level. How Miriam reacts to the abuse — in ways directed both at herself and at her tormentors — forms the climax of the story.

This is a short, fast-paced novel peppered with poetry and journal entries. While it can be difficult to empathize with Miriam's unlikable character at times, Miriam's breakdown is still devastating and the story as a whole feels real and potent. Unfortunately, it also seems incredibly derivative of past YA novels, right down to the scene where Miriam inadvertently shaves her eyebrows. While it's important to portray the awful effects of bullying, I couldn't help but feel this theme and these plot points had been covered before. If middle school readers are looking for a realistic novel on being an outsider, "Freak" may be a good choice. Otherwise, I'm not sure I'd recommend it.

Leave a comment

Posted by on December 3, 2007 in Uncategorized


Tags: , , , , ,